Public Media for Alaska's Yukon-Kuskokwim Delta
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
0:00 0:00
Available On Air Stations

After Rejecting Plea Deal, Judge Sentences Pilot Station Man to Five Years

On Thursday at the Bethel Courthouse, Dale Thomas Fancyboy was sentenced to five years in prison for theft and assault after being convicted of breaking into a jail, holding guards at gunpoint, and then stealing a snowmobile to escape. This sentence comes after the presiding judge rejected a deal that would have let Fancyboy out with half the time and more probation. The judge has also taken a dim view of earlier plea deals.  

Judge Dwayne McConnell said at Thursday’s hearing that he did not believe that Dale Fancyboy was going to learn from his mistakes, no matter how much time he got. So he gave him more time, not less.  

“The reason I rejected the other plea, the one that gave you lesser time, was, I think you need to be out of the community as long as I can keep you out of the community. I don’t think it will change anything, other than maybe people will get a rest.”

The judge went on to cite the numerous instances where Fancyboy had broken the law over the years, and the harm he did over those years.

“From Pitka's Point, to Pilot Station, to Marshall, to Saint Mary’s, in one form or another say that they're afraid of you," said McConnell. 

Bethel's District Attorney Michael Gray argued that the probation terms could protect the public.

“Given a sufficient amount of time to serve, I’m always willing to trade essentially double in suspended time because I think it puts the state in a better position to have control over Mr. Fancyboy," said Gray. 

But the judge did not agree.

McConnell earlier sentenced Daniel Misner, another violent offender, to a reduced sentence with probation after he was presented with a finished plea deal by the DA.

In the cases of Fancyboy, Misner, and another case, that of Derek Adams, the DA sought deals for violent offenders with the bulk of the sentence kept in reserve for if and when defendants violated their conditions of release.

Derek Adams ended up back behind bars when he was found selling heroin after his release. Misner is currently out on probation.

In the case of Mr. Fancyboy on Thursday, Judge McConnell put his foot down, saying he wanted to send him away for as long as he could.